Angelo's

Discover Angelo's Pizza in Hayesville, NC—your local favorite for New York-style pizza, stromboli, meatball subs, calzones, and more. Enjoy delicious Italian classics like caprese, cannoli, and vegetarian options. Call +1 828-389-2500 today!

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to Angelo's

Taste the Difference.

Angelo's
Angelo's
Angelo's
Angelo's

Angelo's Pizza Restaurant, located at 45 Main St, Hayesville, NC 28904, welcomes pizza lovers with open arms. This lively restaurant champions New York-style pizza, offering a taste of the Big Apple in every slice. From the moment you step inside, the aroma of freshly baked dough and savory ingredients wraps around you like a warm blanket. Their menu boasts an array of mouthwatering options including stromboli, meatball subs, and calzones, appealing to both classic and adventurous eaters. You can pop in for a quick lunch or gather with friends and family for a hearty dinner. Angelo's makes every dining experience feel special in a community-centric atmosphere, where camaraderie and great food come together.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

45 Main St, Hayesville, NC 28904, United States

Phone

+1 828-389-2500

About

The Culinary Story

Angelo's
Angelo's
Angelo's
Angelo's

Angelo's Pizza Restaurant has established itself as a Hayesville staple. Open daily, it operates with a passion for providing authentic Italian food to its community. The menu is abundant, featuring over 64 delectable options that celebrate the richness of Italian cuisine. Celebrity items include the famed white pizza and the well-loved meatball sub, attracting customers from all around. The chef's specialty lies in the Italian Baked Favorites, especially the calzones and stromboli, which come packed with generous fillings and authentic flavors.

Customers routinely praise the antipasto salad and the vegetarian pizza for their freshness and balance of flavors.

Angelo's stands out not only for its food but also for its dedication to local produce. Many ingredients hail from nearby farms, ensuring each dish bursts with flavor while supporting the local economy. The vibrant atmosphere welcomes families, groups, and individuals, making it ideal for any occasion.

Takeout is a popular option for those pressed for time, so busy locals can still enjoy their favorite dishes at home. Through community events and promotions, Angelo's contributes to Hayesville’s lively social fabric, from sponsoring youth sports teams to hosting pizza-making workshops on weekends.

The restaurant's commitment to quality extends to its service. Staff members are friendly and always willing to share their recommendations.

Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a long-time patron, the goal is to make everyone feel like part of the family. A sense of belonging gets fostered here, with locals often exchanging stories over a favorite slice of pizza. Angelo's truly embodies the spirit of giving. Its mission reflects a desire not only to satiate hunger but also to connect people through the joy of sharing good food.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday11 AM-7:45 PM
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM-7:45 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-7:45 PM
  • Friday11 AM-7:45 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-7:45 PM

Angelo's Pizza is more than just a place to grab a slice; it offers an inviting ambiance perfect for all age groups. The restaurant features cozy seating arrangements that encourage conversation, and the decor pays homage to classic Italian pizzerias. A bustling open kitchen allows diners to see the chefs in action, baking piping-hot pies right before their eyes. With peak times on busy Fridays at 5 PM, reservations can help avoid long waits. The restaurant serves lunch during weekdays, ideal for a quick bite or a lunch meeting.

Families love the extensive kids’ menu, while couples often enjoy a romantic pizza night out. Refreshing drinks, including craft beers and wines, are available too, adding to the dining pleasure.

Angelo's

Angelo's boasts a welcoming exterior with bright signage and lush greenery surrounding the entrance, making it easily noticeable from the street. Outdoor seating options provide a casual ambiance for sunny days, allowing you to enjoy your meal while soaking in the local atmosphere. The restaurant's vibe is relaxed yet vibrant, filled with laughter and the enticing noise of dishes being served. Customers often gather outside to chat and savor their pizzas, creating an inviting scene that feels like a community event itself. This fusion of culinary delight and neighborly spirit makes each visit enjoyable.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Came in for lunch with my wife and kids and one of the waitresses instantly took to my 14month old. She asked if she could pick him up when he reached for her and carried him around the restaurant while we ate, you could tell she was a good mother herself. The owner happened to be my waitress and was very kind. You can definitely tell it's a family owned business in the best way. The cheesy breadsticks and sauce are delicious! Even the side salads presentation was beautiful.

C
Christina B.

You know when you go to a pizza place you don't really expect it to be clean? Well that's not this place! Everything is super clean including the ceilings and bathrooms. The pizza we had was an excellent NY style with a nice crisp crust, caramelized, not burnt. Perfect combination of heat and time. This is our third time there, and each time we got a pizza to die for. It was so large compared to the stand I thought It was a Salvador Dali pizza, melting off the edge. What a fine place, I hope they don't change.

R
Richard C.

Me and my family absolutely love this place. The food is delicious. We normally have absolutely phenomenal service. The waitresses and waiters are always so nice to us, but the last time we went, the waitress we had was extremely rude, not only to us but to the elderly man who was sitting behind us.

J
Janice B.

I met some friends for lunch. It was my first time here and I'm always reluctant to visit a pizza place because I'm gluten free. I got the anti pasta salad and it did not disappoint!! Made with mixed greens and delicious toppings . . . yummy! So many pizza joints dismiss their salads but not here. And the staff were super friendly and attentive. I will definitely be back!! Thanks Angelos!!

R
Ruth G.

Tables immediately available Wednesday evening. Service speed was moderate. Refills on drinks a little slow. Lasagna was better than average and a huge portion. Well worth the price. If the lasagna was a touch more robust and the service a little quicker then I would give all 5 stars. I will return. Love the small town vibe there.

R
Richard E.

We have ridden by this place numerous times and today we stopped. We could NOT believe how great this pizza was! Unbelievable crust, copious amounts of toppings, and you can run the gamut and buy by the slice to share. We started with the cheese bread and then shared different slices. I am partial to the Hawaiian with PLENTY of toppings. The White pizza is also a top choice. We made the deviation to order a full 18 half and half to bring back to the campsite and it lasted 5 minutes as everyone grabbed slices. Awesome PIZZA!!!! Give it a try sometime!

L
Larry P.